TOPIC A2

How non-inclusive practice may affect children’s outcomes

Introduction

We have seen the benefi ts of inclusive practice to children’s development. But what do you think might happen if a child was in a setting that did not show inclusive practice?

By law, early years settings have to show that they are meeting children’s needs and are showing inclusive practice. In this section we look at why inclusive practice is so important and why non-inclusive practice can be damaging to children.

Negative effects of non-inclusive practice

There are a number of different ways in which children might be affected by being in a setting that does not demonstrate inclusive practice.

Poor self-image

We have seen that children’s self-image is developing from an early age. It is important for children to learn that they are liked and also that they can do things for themselves. Children can develop poor-self image if they are always reliant on adults to help them or if they see that other children are liked more. Poor self-image means that children start to think they are not as good as other children. Over time this leads to a lack of confi dence.

Low self-efficacy

As well as developing a positive self-image, children need to think that they have the potential to be competent. If the environment or layout of a setting is not suitable for a child, they may often have to wait for help and may need to rely on others to do things for them. This means that children learn to be helpless and passive. This is called ‘learned helplessness’. Over time, this means that children may give up quickly or believe that there is no point in trying to help themselves.

Case study

Aidan is 4 years old. He has signifi cant mobility and physical needs as a result of a birthing injury. He was in a setting where there were no ramps or adaptations. He had to be lifted in and out of his wheelchair. He could not move around easily because the layout had not been changed. He often spent time sitting, waiting for adults to move him from one activity to another. Adults in the setting would dress him because it was quicker for them, even though he could manage tops, shirts and jumpers unaided. His parents were worried that he was ‘giving up’. He is now in an inclusive setting where he can, with some effort, move himself around. Staff also give him time and encouragement to do as much as he can alone.

  1. Why was the fi rst setting not showing inclusive practice?
  2. What were the effects of non-inclusive practice on Aidan?